Order your true size. There is no need to go a half size up on these loafers. I did the half size first and it was to big so I returned and ordered my true size and they fit amazingly.
As with any real leather, there is a break in period. At first, I thought they were a bit narrow and tight. After wearing them a couple of times , they loosened and softened. You dont wear thick socks with these of course. The price and craftsmanship is really on par with other brands.
They fit well and look great! I like the touch of adding a pair of socks in the box as well! Have yet to wear them, but am impressed by the fit and initial level of quality.